Collective Rights
Two incidents, one in Germany and the other in Canada, made me think.
Ezra Levant reports that 175 people came out in the bitter Calgary cold to protest Israel's action in Gaza and support Hamas. In a heavily Jewish neighborhood, one protester waved an Israeli flag--and he wasn't even Jewish.
At one point, the police told that counter-protester that if he didn't leave, he'd be arrested for "inciting civil disorder". I'm not making that up -- the lone pro-Israeli protester was told that, not the 175 people trespassing on the parking lot of a private mall. Maybe that's why the cops were too busy to station someone inside.
Muslims in Germany are similarly volatile, threatening riot at the mere sight of an Israeli flag.
Today, 10.000 people demonstrated against Israel here in my hometown Duisburg (Germany) and to express their solidarity with Hamas. So, my girlfriend and me put two Israel flags out of the windows of our flat in the 3rd floor. During the demonstration which went through our street the police broke into our flat and removed the flag of Israel. The statement of the police was to de-escalate the situation, because many youth demonstrators were on the brink of breaking into our apartment house. Before this they threw snowballs, knifes and stones against our windows and the complete building. We both were standing on the other side of the street and were shocked by seeing a police officer standing in our bedroom and opening the window to get the flag. The picture illustrate this situation. The police acquiesced in the demands of the mob.
I've lived in both countries, and they are very different from the U.S., particular with respect to the concept of individual rights. That concept simply doesn't exist in a way Americans would understand it. They instead emphasize some bizarre, nonsense concept of "collective" or community rights. Its not clear how a community exercises its rights, but usually its some "leader" who is empowered to act on their behalf. Thus Muslims, acting collectively to protest Israel, have the right to make a ruckus, but lone individuals are subject to arrest.
Man I love this country...










